Re: [PATCH 3/5] media: i2c: Add TDA1997x HDMI receiver driver

[Hans Verkuil <hverkuil@xs4all.nl>]

On 14/12/17 00:33, Tim Harvey wrote:
> On Tue, Dec 12, 2017 at 4:18 AM, Hans Verkuil <hverkuil@xs4all.nl> wrote:
>> Hi Tim,
>>
>> Sorry for the delay, I needed to find some time to think about this.
>>
>> On 11/16/17 05:30, Rob Herring wrote:
>>> On Wed, Nov 15, 2017 at 10:31:14AM -0800, Tim Harvey wrote:
>>>> On Wed, Nov 15, 2017 at 7:52 AM, Rob Herring <robh@kernel.org> wrote:
>>>>> On Thu, Nov 09, 2017 at 10:45:34AM -0800, Tim Harvey wrote:
>>>>>> Add support for the TDA1997x HDMI receivers.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Cc: Hans Verkuil <hverkuil@xs4all.nl>
>>>>>> Signed-off-by: Tim Harvey <tharvey@gateworks.com>
>>>>>> ---
>>>>>> v3:
>>>>>>  - use V4L2_DV_BT_FRAME_WIDTH/HEIGHT macros
>>>>>>  - fixed missing break
>>>>>>  - use only hdmi_infoframe_log for infoframe logging
>>>>>>  - simplify tda1997x_s_stream error handling
>>>>>>  - add delayed work proc to handle hotplug enable/disable
>>>>>>  - fix set_edid (disable HPD before writing, enable after)
>>>>>>  - remove enabling edid by default
>>>>>>  - initialize timings
>>>>>>  - take quant range into account in colorspace conversion
>>>>>>  - remove vendor/product tracking (we provide this in log_status via infoframes)
>>>>>>  - add v4l_controls
>>>>>>  - add more detail to log_status
>>>>>>  - calculate vhref generator timings
>>>>>>  - timing detection fixes (rounding errors, hswidth errors)
>>>>>>  - rename configure_input/configure_conv functions
>>>>>>
>>>>>> v2:
>>>>>>  - implement dv timings enum/cap
>>>>>>  - remove deprecated g_mbus_config op
>>>>>>  - fix dv_query_timings
>>>>>>  - add EDID get/set handling
>>>>>>  - remove max-pixel-rate support
>>>>>>  - add audio codec DAI support
>>>>>>  - change audio bindings
>>>>>> ---
>>>>>>  drivers/media/i2c/Kconfig            |    9 +
>>>>>>  drivers/media/i2c/Makefile           |    1 +
>>>>>>  drivers/media/i2c/tda1997x.c         | 3485 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
>>>>>>  include/dt-bindings/media/tda1997x.h |   78 +
>>>>>
>>>>> This belongs with the binding documentation patch.
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Rob,
>>>>
>>>> Thanks - missed that. I will move it for v4.
>>>>
>>>> Regarding your previous comment to the v2 series:
>>>>> The rest of the binding looks fine, but I have some reservations about
>>>>> this. I think this should be common probably. There's been a few
>>>>> bindings for display recently that deal with the interface format. Maybe
>>>>> some vendor property is needed here to map a standard interface format
>>>>> back to pin configuration.
>>>>
>>>> I take it this is not an 'Ack' for the bindings?
>>>>
>>>> Which did you feel should be made common? I admit I was surprised
>>>> there wasn't a common binding for audio bus format (i2s|spdif) but if
>>>> you were referring to the video data that would probably be much more
>>>> complicated.
>>>
>>> The video data. Either you have to try to come up with some way to map
>>> color components to signals/pins (and even cycles) or you just enumerate
>>> the formats and keep adding to them when new ones appear. There's h/w
>>> that allows the former, but in the end you have to interoperate, so
>>> enumerating the formats is probably enough.
>>>
>>>> I was hoping one of the media/driver maintainers would respond to your
>>>> comment with thoughts as I'm not familiar with a very wide variety of
>>>> receivers.
>>>
>>> I am hoping, too.
>>
>> I don't think it is right to store this in the DT. How you map the output pins
>> is a driver thing. So when you are requested to enumerate the mediabus formats
>> (include/uapi/linux/media-bus-format.h) you support, you do so based on the
>> capabilities of the hardware, and when a format is requested you program the
>> hardware accordingly.
>>
>> The device tree should describe the physical characteristics like the number
>> of pins that are hooked up (i.e. are there 24, 30 or 36 pins connected).
>>
>> These vidout-portcfg mappings do not appear to describe physical properties
>> but really register settings.
> 
> Hans,
> 
> They are register settings that define which bits on the internal data
> bus are mapped to which pins on the package. Internally these parts
> have a 36bit video data bus but externally the tda19971 only has 24
> pins and even then perhaps only 8 are hooked up if using BT656 and the
> registers also define 'which 8' as it could have been connected to the
> upper or lower part of the bus. So while the bindings from
> video-interfaces.txt provide bus-width and details of the sync
> signals, additional hardware-specific interconnect details such as how
> the video bits are shifted/mixed on the output bus are needed here.
> This is why I feel vidout-portcfg should be a dt property vs something
> like a module param.

The video-interfaces.txt bindings text defines bus-width and data-shift.
The last one would define 'which 8'.

Only if the hardware can do weird stuff like using pins 4-7 and 16-19 would
this be insufficient. But in that case we would need something more detailed
in video-interfaces.txt.

Frankly, unless you've seen anyone do something weird like that I would stick
to bus-width and data-shift.

Regards,

	Hans